Bar chart comparing cost per lead year over year. Meta lead ads fell from $91.79 to $65.30 (down 29%); Google Performance Max fell from $119.39 to $13.98 (down 88%).

How a multi-brand Medicare Advantage enrollment campaign generated 14,962 leads in ten weeks and sharply cut cost per lead on its two largest channels.

14,962

calls and form leads in 10 weeks

88%

lower Performance Max cost per lead vs. 2024

29%

lower Meta cost per lead vs. 2024

At a glance

  • Client: ChenMed (four senior primary care brands: Chen Senior Medical, Dedicated Senior Medical, JenCare, and IntuneHealth)
  • Industry: Healthcare, Medicare Advantage primary care
  • Timeline: Medicare Annual Enrollment Period (AEP), October 1 – December 7, 2025
  • Channels: Facebook/Instagram lead ads, Google Performance Max, Google Search, programmatic display, native, and social
  • Scope: 24 individual markets across 12 states
  • My role: account lead in planning, buying, reporting, and client management

The challenge

AEP is the most competitive window of the year for Medicare advertisers, and every one of the 24 markets had its own geography, brand, and audience. The 2024 campaign had been essentially a pilot: Performance Max was brand new to the account, and it ran in a crowded media environment between typical Q4 competition and an election season.

Client expectations for the year were high, as we enacted learnings from previous AEP campaigns and managed unprecedented close control over creative messaging. Our team needed to provide leads at a more cost effective rate than in the past.

The strategy

Building on the 2024 pilot and on that summer’s Turning 65 and New Movers campaigns, each channel was given a distinct job in the funnel:

  • Meta lead ads drove the bulk of form leads with market-level targeting.
  • Google Performance Max and Search captured high-intent prospects ready to call.
  • Programmatic display, native, and social built awareness higher in the funnel with click-to-call ads.
Bar chart comparing cost per lead year over year. Meta lead ads fell from $91.79 to $65.30 (down 29%); Google Performance Max fell from $119.39 to $13.98 (down 88%).

The results

  • Performance Max: cost per lead fell from $119.39 in 2024 to $13.98, against a $100 benchmark, with a 3.95% CTR (benchmark 3%).
  • Meta: cost per lead fell from $91.79 to $65.30, against an $85 benchmark, with a 1.73% CTR (benchmark 1.5%).
  • Google Search: $23.07 cost per lead against a $50 benchmark, on par with the account’s best quarters even during the final push to deliver in full.
  • Overall: 14,962 calls and form leads at a $35.47 blended cost per lead, with nearly full delivery of the media budget.

Creative insight

Copy analysis showed which messages earned the most response. “When patients call, we answer.” drove the most clicks of any headline (3.84% CTR), while “Get the Care You Deserve” earned the highest click-through rate at 5.71%. Messaging about personalized care consistently outperformed generic availability messaging.

What I learned

Not every tactic fits every funnel stage. Programmatic click-to-call ads built broad awareness but offered little lead visibility, and spend stalled late in the flight. The recommendation going forward was to optimize that channel toward the awareness it already drives well.

Google Ads were the standout success and a major conversion driver. These results led to our team taking a much closer look at their utility and impact.


Related services: Media Placement · Digital Expertise · Book a call →



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search

About

I’m Rebekah Rae Mullins, a digital media specialist who plans, buys, and optimizes omnichannel campaigns for healthcare, government, tourism, education, and consumer brands.

These case studies and samples show how I find clarity in complexity and turn it into measurable results. More about me →

Tags

Get Connected

Work With Me

Currently open to full-time and freelance opportunities.